What I'm thinking is tying the position maxes to different coach styles for your head coach. So just for transparency I'm going to open it up for discussion here. I'm going to leave K/P at 3/3 for all formations.
Keep in mind this is just CPU Teams or Auto Recruit enabled teams. In 4.0.3 the human teams can already exceed these maxes.
So for defense what changes to position maxes would you make for each defense variant:
D34,
D43,
D335,
D34Hybrid,
D43Hybrid,
D335Hybrid,
D52,
D52Hybrid
Current defaults are 34 players:
CB: 6
LB: 8
DT: 6
DE: 6
FS: 4
SS: 4
Which changes for Offense Variants:
WestCoast,
Power,
Spread,
ProStyle,
Vertical,
WestCoastHybrid,
PowerHybrid,
SpreadHybrid,
ProStyleHybrid,
VerticalHybrid,
SmashMouthHybrid
Current Offense Defaults (45 players):
QB: 4
RB: 6
FB: 4
G: 5
T: 5
C: 5
TE: 6
WR: 10
Let me know in the comments below what the desired changes are and see if we can come to a consensus.