I noticed that a player on my watch list is listed as a 1 star player when I only look at in-state players (texas in this case).

But when I look at the entire Great Plains Region, he shows as a three star player.

Is this just a glitch or are players rated differently based on the list you select?

I really don't understand how that can be the case. For the recruit rankings, it's seemed to me that the star system is related to the recruit's ranking overall (not by state or by region). I'd suggest you point out which player it is in a Support Ticket and send you game files in so Gary can check it out.

Yeah I would like to check out the files - please let me know the player so I can check it out when you send your files in.

I'm gonna guess that he chose the NXT HOOPS Great Plains section instead of the Regular Great Plains recruits page. Some 1-Star guys are shown as 3-Star guys on NXT HOOPS.

That is exactly what I did.

I just double checked. On regular plains I have three one stars on my list. On the NXT list they show up as three and four star players.

Yep, makes you have a double-take on those guys (are they actually better than some 2-Stars?) So you need to take a close look which are Scouting Notes every week