I am in my 3rd season with my Crimson Tide and lately I have been having to reset the pause at all stops option before some games.
It usually happens when watching back to back games.

Is anyone else having to do this?

I do. But if I go to Game Options, turn on Pause at All Stops then turn it off again it fixes the problem for the rest of that game. It's a p.i.t.a. though.

Yep! That's it! I have to do the same thing.