Star Rating Differences

[coachwf]

What is the difference between the WSSN projection star rating and the NXT Hoops star ratings. WSSN and state ratings seem to be much lower than NXT Hoops.

[Gary Gorski]

Two different rating services - different criteria and margin of error and scope of recruits go into each one. You have to judge for yourself which one you find to be more accurate and useful.

[coachwf]

Thanks Gary. Also noticed my players potential starts changing once I start games. I assume that is supposed to happen and is based on their performance?

[Gary Gorski]

Yes once they come to your team then the ratings are going to be based on the ratings of you and your coaching staff. You may find they could be wildly different at that point especially if you and your coaches have low skills.

[coachwf]

I actually meant my existing roster, not recruits. First season, made a depth plan based on ratings and potential. After I played 2 games those potential stars are different for my existing players.

[Gary Gorski]

Yes the ratings are reevaluated for all players every season at multiple points

[coachwf]

Awesome, thanks for the feedback!

[EasyBreecy]

Hopping on to this because while I understand ratings may change, I don't understand what to believe. I had a redshirt freshman go from 3/4.5 stars to 0.5/0.5 from the transfer period to start of recruiting. Redshirted an incoming frosh because he didn't care about playing and was listed as 1/3.5 and is now listed as 2/4.5 and I can't remove the redshirt. Had another incoming frosh go from 4/4.5 to 1.5/1.5. I'm not complaining, I'm just trying to understand.

[gord]

I'm in the same boat. One player jumped from a 2.0 to a 4.0 in the same season, and by the beginning of the next season, he went down to a 2.5. I understand development isn't linear but it's hard to get a good grasp of what I have talent-wise with so many jumps.

[Gary Gorski]

Hopping on to this because while I understand ratings may change, I don't understand what to believe. I had a redshirt freshman go from 3/4.5 stars to 0.5/0.5 from the transfer period to start of recruiting. Redshirted an incoming frosh because he didn't care about playing and was listed as 1/3.5 and is now listed as 2/4.5 and I can't remove the redshirt. Had another incoming frosh go from 4/4.5 to 1.5/1.5. I'm not complaining, I'm just trying to understand.

The frosh you redshirted being a 1/3.5 v 2/4.5 isn't too concerning for me. You bring him in and the coaches think he's not very good and you redshirt him and later on he's either improved or the coaches think he's improved but still if he's only a 2 star player what difference would it make in removing the redshirt? Would you have been playing him a ton if you thought he was a 2 star and not a 1 star?

Having a guy you signed in the portal as 3.0 and then being seen as a 0.5 is concerning though. Did you scout that player during the portal or did you previously scout him during the season because he was an opponent? If you look under HELP in the game and see the instructions to send in the game files and tell me the players to look at I will see if I can run it through a couple times and see what kind of changes happen and see if something is wrong in the scouting area.