Feedback Part 1: Training, Progression, Playbooks/Strategies

[servo75]

Hi guys, great game so far. I've just been making a categorized list and adding to it as I go. I'll try to keep these as organized as possible by topic.

Training and Progression:
* You made a change in Pro last year to get the player progression graph into chart form. This was really helpful since the graph is very hard to read. Could the table format be added to the college game? Actually right now I can't even see the ratings from hovering the mouse over.
* Also another idea, in the progression list at the right side of the screen, could the up/down arrows be replaced with actual +- numbers? So instead of just saying, Week 1 - Speed up, it could say Week 1 - Speed +2. Would really help to track player progress

Playcalling/strategies/playbooks:
* It would be helpful in custom playbooks to have
- More ways to sort and filter plays both in the playbook and in the play list. For example, maybe sort the playbook by average yards, or in the list of plays, filter by pass length, scheme, etc.
- A quick way to test custom plays. Right now have to add them to a playbook, add the playbook to strategies, then play a season game with that team, and have the play called over and over.
* Could we be able to save playcalling strategies (playbooks, run/pass weights, etc.) the same way we can save game plans now?
* Play Analysis:
- The Play Analysis screen shows offense plays run by myself and opponent(s). Can the play analysis also show defensive plays? Right now I can see defense averages in the playbook view but not play analysis so can't be used to scout opponents.
- Could the play analysis also show standard deviation (level of variation) in addition to average play gain? They're just as important IMHO
- Is there a reason why in offense playbooks, we can see the % of the weight for run and pass but not in the defensive playbooks it just says _%?

[hansmellman]

Training and Progression:
* You made a change in Pro last year to get the player progression graph into chart form. This was really helpful since the graph is very hard to read. Could the table format be added to the college game? Actually right now I can't even see the ratings from hovering the mouse over.
* Also another idea, in the progression list at the right side of the screen, could the up/down arrows be replaced with actual +- numbers? So instead of just saying, Week 1 - Speed up, it could say Week 1 - Speed +2. Would really help to track player progress

Both great points, the graph is not ideal imo and especially without the added tooltip(even then though it would be great if this info graphic could be altered to provide more clarity).

[garrettjones331]

In regards to your game plan suggestion, I made an expanded suggestion for that in PF viewtopic.php?f=371&t=37274